Best Thermal Coffee Maker

We believe that a coffee maker with a thermal carafe is better than a coffee maker with a glass carafe. We also believe that you should upgrade to a thermal carafe coffee maker if you’re looking for a new machine to brew your everyday coffee.

But don’t take our word for it.

Read on to learn what they’re all about and uncover if they’re worth your time.

If we’re on the same page about them, an in-depth review of the 5 best thermal carafes awaits.

Let’s begin:

What is a thermal coffee maker?

A thermal coffee maker is a coffee maker with a thermal carafe.

A thermal carafe is a metal pot in which the coffee falls into after the machine is finished brewing the coffee beans. This type of carafe is generally made of metals like stainless steel or aluminum.

Thermal Carafe or Glass Carafe?

We all love the aesthetics of a glass carafe. It is a sight for sore eyes. It is also extremely helpful because it shows the quantity of coffee present in the glass container at a given time. But this is not a good enough reason to crown them the ‘king of carafes’. We are of the opinion that a thermal carafe is better than them.

Here are 3 reasons explaining what makes a thermal carafe the better choice:

A thermal carafe keeps your coffee warmer for a much longer period of time

If your coffee brewer comes with a glass carafe, you might end up hating your coffee re-runs because they won’t be as warm and delicious as the first cup. Like any other person, you will end up re-heating your coffee. But guess what? You won’t like it either because it will end up tasting burnt and bitter. What went wrong?

We blame the glass carafe. You probably didn’t know this but glass carafes are not the best insulators. To compensate for it, most of them have a heating plate attached at the bottom to keep coffee warm.

However, the warming plate is not good enough because it ends up burning your coffee. It hardly maintains the coffee heat because there is no natural insulation. It’s good enough to store your brewed coffee in it but not good enough to retain its warmth. So if you like to take your time with your coffee, a coffee maker with a glass carafe is a big no.

This is where a thermal carafe shines in comparison. It has an insulated design that keeps coffee hot. There is no need for reheating because the metal component of the carafe retains the temperature of your coffee for a longer duration than a glass carafe.

If you like coming back to a hot cup of coffee, this is the coffee maker you should bet on.

Glass isn’t the gold standard for durability

Thermal carafes are carafes that are made of metal whereas glass carafes are made of glass.

Drop a thermal carafe and it might leave a dent. Drop a glass carafe and it will break into pieces.

It is obvious that a thermal carafe wins the durability test here.

While a glass carafe looks all nice and modern, it does not bring much to the table. It does not keep your coffee hot or stay intact for a long time. Unless you’re extremely meticulous, your glass carafe won’t live to see old age. So if you have butterfingers, then do yourself a favor and get a machine with a thermal carafe.

A thermal carafe is dishwasher-safe

The third area where this carafe outshines its glass counterpart is in its cleaning effectiveness.

Unless your coffee maker comes with an extremely durable glass carafe, the thermal carafe is the better choice for cleaning in a dishwasher.

It makes drinking coffee extra special because you don’t need to worry about trivial things like post-coffee cleaning. Leave it to the dishwasher and enjoy your day.

Top 5 things to look for in a thermal coffeemaker:

Now that we have established that thermal carafes are better than the glass variety, let’s move on to the next phase.

Knowing that you want a thermal carafe coffee maker is the first step. Knowing what to look for in the coffee maker is the next. So here’s a list of the top things to look for in a thermal coffeemaker:

Choose an SCA certified thermal coffeemaker

Why settle for an average coffeemaker when you can have a thermal coffeemaker that is SCA certified?

All SCA certified thermal coffeemakers are branded with the seal of perfection. An SCA certification is a hallmark of competence as it demonstrates that it has passed the quality tests outlined by this apex coffee association.

From the brewing process to brew time to water temperature to beverage preparation to uniformity of extraction & performance; all SCA certified thermal coffee brewers have met and passed the quality test.

So if you have the budget, and want to invest in the best coffee maker, look for SCA approved thermal coffee makers.

Choose a stainless steel carafe over an aluminum carafe

We believe that while choosing a thermal carafe coffee maker, you should look for carafes made of stainless steel. It is a better alternative to the aluminum variety as it lasts longer.

But this is not the only factor. Read on to learn what makes it an obvious pick:

  • Strength & Durability: Stainless steel is a stronger metal than aluminum. It is less malleable which means that it is less likely to get a dent or undergo chipping. It is also more corrosion-resistant than aluminum which means that is less likely to rust over time. The verdict? It is more durable.
  • Coffee Taste & Health Factor: Aluminum can be a bit of a health disaster as it imparts extremely small amounts of trace metals into your coffee if the pot is not well seasoned. This negatively impacts the taste of your coffee brew, giving it a metallic taste that most people hate. When evaluating both metals on the health and taste aspect, stainless steel delivers.
  • Cleaning: Stainless steel carafes are also easier to clean than their aluminum counterparts. Its chrome property makes it easier to wash and wipe the coffee gunk off the carafe.

Choose a thermal coffeemaker that retains the brew temperature

A hot beverage is a good beverage.

A simple statement like this holds more weight in the coffee world than it does on the outside. After all, we all love the taste of piping hot coffee and detest the taste of room-temperature coffee (unless that’s what you prefer).

The best coffee makers can brew your coffee and maintain it at the ideal temperature range (92 degrees celsius – 96 degrees celsius). Our suggestion?

Look for a thermal carafe coffee maker that can consistently brew and maintain this temperature range because not even a thermal coffeemaker can keep your coffee hot and delicious for a long time if the coffeemaker can’t get the water temperature to its optimum level.

Choose a carafe with a large capacity

‘Go big or go home’ is a tagline that resonates with us.

The same philosophy holds true with coffee makers too. After all, size matters.

There is no point in getting a coffee maker that is too small to accommodate your ever-growing coffee appetite. This is why we believe that an ideal thermal carafe coffee maker should have a large holding capacity.

Go for one that holds a minimum of 8 cups of coffee. But ideally, we would suggest a coffee machine that can hold 12 cups of coffee. Doing this eliminates the need to brew another batch as your carafe can hold a large quantity.

This way, all you have to do is brew your coffee once and enjoy hot coffee for a long long time.

Choose a programmable coffeemaker with mid-brew and auto-off features

Modern coffee makers come with exciting new features & controls that are designed to make your life a little easier.

These days, the latest coffeemakers come with a 24-hour programmable timer. Meaning: you can schedule your coffee in advance, right before you go to bed. This means longer sleep time and caffeinated mornings. Look for this feature in your next buy for a hassle-free experience and laidback coffee delights.

Next up is the brew-pause and pour feature. If you ‘hate to wait’ for coffee, would like to steal a cup before the brewing cycle completes, then this is a feature you should look for in a thermal coffeemaker.

The last and most precious of them all is the auto-off feature. There are days when you are more forgetful than usual. In days like this, you might potentially forget to switch off your coffee machine, leave home and remember all about it when you are mid-way to work, just to come running back to switch it off.

Trust us when we say this – you don’t want this headache.

So look for a coffeemaker that switches off automatically within an hour of brewing coffee.

Product Review: 5 Best Thermal Carafe Coffee Makers

Your search for the best thermal carafe coffee makers end today.

We have done an in-depth review of the 5 coffee makers of the thermal variety to help you pick a great product with the specifications and budget that suits your needs.

Read on to learn all about them.

OXO BREW

SPECIFICATIONS

  • Dimensions: 8.3 x 15 x 17.2 inches
  • Capacity: 9 cups
  • Metal Composition: Stainless steel & plastic

The OXO Brew Coffee Maker best represents the goodness of modern-day coffee machines that are built to satisfy the caffeine junkie in you. If you are looking for coffee makers with a 24-hour programmable timer, this is it. It has features like the LED interface that indicates coffee freshness and brewing status. Highly intelligent and built to last, this product makes your life easier with the push of a button.

You can also select the brew quantity and opt for small or large dozes based on your needs. Talk about flavor, its well-thought internal mixing tube sees to it that your brew tastes delicious at all times. The double-walled carafe is designed to keep your coffee hot and delicious – just how you like it.

However, if you are looking for a 12 cup coffee maker, this unit will disappoint. With a 9 cup coffee capacity, it does not make an ideal coffeemaker to keep coming to fo refills. But then again, this is a small price to pay for the mammoth of goodness and quality-assured brewing that comes with this unit.

PROS:

  • SCA Certified.
  • Freshness timer (turns off after 1 hour).
  • 24-hour programmable timer.
  • Carafe lid and filter basket are dishwasher safe.
  • Brew pause feature.
  • Insulated double-walled carafe guarantees coffee warmth.
  • Rainmaker shower head guarantees optimum & full flavor extraction.

CONS:

  • Too tall to fit in most kitchen cabinets.
  • Single dial for all controls.
  • No options to control temperature and infusion rate.

Zojirushi EC-YSC100 Fresh Brew Plus 

SPECIFICATIONS

  • Dimensions: 8 x 11.1 x 14.9 inches
  • Capacity: 12 cups
  • Metal Composition: Stainless steel

The Zojirushi Fresh Brew Plus Coffee Maker has a touch of professionalism like nothing you’ve ever seen. What makes this unit extra special is its four-way warming plate setting which is designed to keep your coffee warm at all times at your preferred temperature – high, medium, low, and off – it covers it all.

Nothing puts the ‘good’ in your morning as this machine does. Its 24-hour programmable timer sees to it that you wake up to the smell of auto-brewed coffee that you can pre-schedule for your morning kicks. What’s more, this machine also comes with a cleanliness indicator to alert you every time your machine needs a wash. Its auto-off feature is also a big hit as it helps save electricity and prevents a potential fire hazard.

It also comes with a 200°F high brewing temperature for superior flavor extraction – this means that hot or iced, every coffee cup is brewed to its maximum potential. Extra thought is given to the iced coffee too, which is brewed using the Japanese Iced Coffee Method for superior clarity, complexity, and aroma.

What’s not to love? Now that’s a coffee machine you should bank on!

PROS:

  • Removable water tank ensures easy cleaning.
  • 24-hour programmable timer & automatic shut-off.
  • Easy-pour carafe with clean spout design minimizes dribbling.
  • Clean indicator alert signals when your machine needs cleaning.
  • Keeps coffee warm at your preferred temperature - HI, MED, LOW and OFF

CONS:

  • Emits a lot of steam.
  • On the expensive price range.
  • Noisy: beeps loudly when the coffee is done brewing.
  • Might randomly overflow and spill grinds and coffee.
  • Brewing large brews (12 cups), the filter basket overflows and gets grounds into the carafe.

BLACK+DECKER 12-cup Thermal Coffeemaker

SPECIFICATIONS

  • Dimensions: 8 x 11 x 11.5 inches
  • Capacity: 12 cups
  • Metal Composition: Stainless steel

Nothing can keep coffee warm like the Black+Decker CM2035B Coffeemaker. It has a vacuum-sealed and double-walled carafe to keep coffee warm at optimal drinking temperature, making it an ideal brewer for hot coffee lovers.

This 12-cup thermal coffeemaker has customizable brewing options like the brew strength selector and small-batch selector making this coffee brewer extremely customizable and an absolute favorite. Its meticulously designed Evenstream Showerhead guarantees maximum flavor extraction and fresh coffee at all times.

What’s more? This coffee brewer is incredibly easy to use and clean. Its wide-mouth carafe sprout makes it extremely easy to pour coffee without creating a mess. The LCD display is an added feature and a big USP with this model. It includes a fresh brew timer that indicates how much time has passed since the coffee was brewed for up to 2 hours.

PROS:

  • Budget-friendly.
  • LCD Backlit Display.
  • Guaranteed fresh brew plus optimal temperature.
  • Customized brewing options & brew strength selector.
  • Small batch selection option (1-4 cups).
  • Vacuum-sealed and double-walled carafe maintains the optimal temperature.

CONS:

  • Durability is not guaranteed.
  • No filter is supplied with the machine.
  • No back-up for power failure: loses time with a moment of power fail.
  • Text on buttons wears off too quickly.

Mr Coffee BVMC-PSTX95

SPECIFICATIONS

  • Dimensions: 8.7 x 13.1 x 14.3 inches
  • Capacity: 10 cups
  • Metal Composition: Stainless steel

Highly intelligent and pocket-friendly, the designers of Mr Coffee Coffeemaker have outdone themselves with this model. If you want a great coffeemaker at a budget, this unit is custom-made for you. This coffee machine comes with a removable water tank and filter basket lift out which makes it easy to use, fill, and clean.

Satiating your caffeine hunger at the speed of light, this machine brews a full pot of coffee in a short brew time of just 7 minutes. What’s more? Its brew-pause feature lets you steal a quick cup of coffee while the machine is busy brewing your coffee beans.

PROS:

  • Budget-friendly.
  • Removable water reservoir.
  • Included water filtration disk filters.
  • Gasket between carafe and dripper keeps coffee warm.
  • Water Filtration Disk filters out chlorine and impurities from water.

CONS:

  • Water reservoir and filter on opposite sides – need clearance on both sides.
  • Undesirable steam emission (not recommended under wooden cabinets).

Technivorm 79112 KBT Coffee Brewer

SPECIFICATIONS

  • Dimensions: 11.5 x 6.8 x 15.2 inches
  • Capacity: 10 cups
  • Metal Composition: Polished silver

Trust us when we say this, you will fall in love with the Technivorm 79112 KBT Coffee Brewer. The elegant design and modern look of this 10 cup coffee maker makes it the best coffee maker in the looks department. Great aesthetics is not its only USP, this machine also triumphs in quick service and taste delivery.

Talk about performance, this coffee maker has a quick brew time that closely resembles the lightning-speed service of a Michelin star restaurant (you get the jest). Believe it or not, this unit can brew a full pot of coffee in just 4 to 6 minutes, making it an irresistible buy for coffee junkies who hate the wait-time of a slowly brewed coffee.

Another major attraction of this coffee unit is its ability to brew your coffee at optimal temperatures (96º to 205º F ) which gives you a balanced brew that is neither over-extracted nor under-extracted.

All these features combined make it one of the best coffeemakers on this list. But it also makes it slightly expensive too. This might not be ideal for coffee lovers with a budget.

PROS:

  • It has a large capacity of 10 cups.
  • Quick brew time of four to six minutes.
  • The metal carafe can keep coffee hot for a longer time.
  • The copper-based boiling system ensures optimal brewing temperature.

CONS:

  • It is on the expensive price range.
  • The cone filter is difficult to clean.
  • The coffee grounds might spillover while brewing.

What is the best thermal coffee brewer?

If you’re asking the million-dollar question “what is the best coffee maker with thermal carafe?”, we’ll tell you that there is no clear-cut answer.

What is best for someone else is not necessarily best for you. So we have attempted to answer this question by giving you our selection of the best thermal carafe coffee makers on this list based on 5 different categories:

  • Coffeemaker with the maximum capacity: With the ability to hold 12 cups of coffee, the Black+Decker CM2035B Coffeemaker and the Zojirushi EC-YGC12 Coffee Maker are best designed for people with big caffeine appetites.
  • Most affordable coffeemaker: If you’re looking for a pocket-friendly coffee maker with thermal carafe, the Mr Coffee Coffeemaker is the best on this list for you.
  • Most programmable coffeemaker: With its highly programmable auto-brew and auto-off function, the Black+Decker Coffeemaker tops the list. At a close second comes the OXO Brew Coffee Maker which comes with a 24-hour programmable timer and brew pause feature.
  • Best overall coffeemaker: We believe that the Technivorm 79112 KBT Coffee Brewer tops this list. Its decent capacity, quick brewing time, and optimal brewing temperature make this an absolute winner. If money is no limitation, get your hands on this coffee brewing machine.

What else can we say? Go get a thermal coffeemaker already!